The AMD FX-8320/8350 vs Intel i5-4460/4960K Showdown

0
June 25, 2016

So I am planning my new build and have run a cheeky wee £110 over budget on a £450 build so as you can imagine I am trying to find ways to shave off as much money as possible.

My planned setup is this:

http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/p/NVwKxr

So, looking at the most expensive parts (GPU & CPU) I am Looking for ways to go for a cheaper CPUs without losing too much processing ability.

I have narrowed it down to the AMD FX-8350, AMD FX-8320, Intel i5-4460 and the i5 4690k. The i5-4690k is my ideal choice as it blows away the competition in both gaming and productivity which brings me onto what I would be using this build for:

-Gaming

(Skyrim, BF4, Garrys Mod, TF2, and yes, minecraft)

-Design

(2D & 3D Work using mainly autodesk inventor for the 3D work and AutoCAD for the 2D work)

-Animation

(both 2D & 3D work using mainly Auytodesk Maya/blender for the 3D work and some other

unknown software for 2D work)

-Content Creation

(Video rendering and editing)

I know for productivity the AMD cores win by about 20% but I know for gaming the i5s win by about 50% (at stock speeds) so it leaves me stuck as to what to do and what processer to go with.

I am also aware that my motherbard is

not

ideal so I am aware I need to look into that and I reckon I can get about £10-15 off there and I am aware my GPU is crazy expensive for my build and so I am debating whether to cut down on that to about an £130-140 GPU in which case I could go with the i5-4960K.

Please help me with what I should do at this point as I feel it could swing the usefulness of my build depending on what I do at this stage and I am not looking to waste £500 on something that doesn't do what I need it to do.

Cheers for the help.

Comments See all(0)

Add comment
0
June 25, 2016

Hello :

  • Gaming : i5 wins

  • AutoCAD : i5 wins for the single threaded power

  • Blender, maya : FX wins by number of cores

  • Video editing : FX wins by far

So you have to fix your priorities before choosing your CPU, because :

  • For K CPU : Z97 mobo

  • If K or AMD CPU, you should take an aftermarket cooler

  • For AutoCAD, you need a Quadro

  • For Blender, you need a GTX for Cycles

0
June 25, 2016

In all applications where 4 cores and under are utilized a I5 4690K will blow away everything AMD has to offer and that is before you even start to overclock. If your doing a tasks that utilizes more than 4 cores then the FX 8350/8320 will pull away but not by a large margin. For the range of software you plan on using you might want to consider a Xeon E3-1230, Xeon E3-1240V3 or Xeon E3-1241 v3 all of which run about the same price as a I5 4690K AMD blow away FX chips in the software you listed.

0
June 25, 2016

I can see why you would need one but I am already

extremely

over budget so are there anyone cheap ones you would recommend that would still get the job done until I can upgrade in 4-5 months time?

0
June 25, 2016

Are the xeon chips overclockable? AMD by looking at the specs they don't look any different, if not worse than the 4960K, so what what is the difference between the xeon series and the i5 series

0
June 25, 2016

I agree with AHBman for his statements, and yes, you will need a aftermarket heatsink if you are using an Intel K part or an AMD FX CPU. I recommend the Cooler Master Hyper212 EVO if you are going to have a heatsink. One of my friends uses an AMD 8350 in his rig and has comparable frame rates to my Intel core i7 4770K. The Intel i5 CPUs have very similar performance numbers to the AMD counterparts, maybe a bit better. If you are going to be doing things like game streaming or video encoding and editing, the AMD FX 8350 will be perfect for your build, and should be a bit cheaper than the Intel i5 series. If you do stick with your current set-up, make sure you choose a motherboard that supports overclocking if you want to take advantage of that 'K' on the end of the i5, as I'm not sure how many of the H97 motherboards do. If you want one that will certainly support overclocking, go for a Z97 series motherboard. Personally, I use an i7 chip, but I know people that use the AMD 8-core options, and I know for a fact that they are good, high performance, quality chips that can easily be overclocked with most motherboards. I hope this helps and good luck with your build!

:D

0
June 25, 2016

the 280x requires a 750 watts powersupply. the i5 4460 is the best when it comes to price/performance and you can get away with a cheap h81 mobo with it as you are not able to overclock it. but better go amd build you won't notice any difference in gaming because the 280x is not that powerful compared to gtx 970/980 or r9 290/290x.

0
June 25, 2016

PCPartPicker part list

/

Price breakdown by merchant

CPU:

Intel Xeon E3-1230 V3 3.3GHz Quad-Core Processor

(£185.94 @ Aria PC)

Motherboard:

MSI B85M-P33 V2 Micro ATX LGA1150 Motherboard

(£39.39 @ Amazon UK)

Memory:

G.Skill Ripjaws X Series 8GB (2 x 4GB) DDR3-1600 Memory

(£58.69 @ Ebuyer)

Storage:

Seagate Barracuda 1TB 3.5" 7200RPM Internal Hard Drive

(£35.94 @ Aria PC)

Video Card:

MSI Radeon R9 280 3GB TWIN FROZR Video Card

(£149.14 @ Scan.co.uk)

Case:

NZXT Source 210 (Black) ATX Mid Tower Case

(£30.25 @ Scan.co.uk)

Power Supply:

EVGA 500W 80+ Bronze Certified ATX Power Supply

(£36.98 @ Novatech)

Total:

£536.33

Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available

Generated by PCPartPicker 2014-12-28 17:48 GMT+0000

This'll work for both design and games

0
June 25, 2016

That is pretty handy to know as all the bench marks and speed tests seem to

love

slagging off the AMD series

0
June 25, 2016

the 4690k won't help you without a Z series motherboard.

you can get by just fine with a cheap H81 board.

Raise your budget 450 is bare minimum for a GAMING PC, you'll be using your pc to make money, in the real world you'd likely be dropping 2000 on it easy.

PCPartPicker part list

/

Price breakdown by merchant

CPU:

Intel Core i5-4460 3.2GHz Quad-Core Processor

(£130.94 @ Aria PC)

Motherboard:

MSI H81M-P33 Micro ATX LGA1150 Motherboard

(£32.17 @ Scan.co.uk)

Memory:

G.Skill Ripjaws X Series 8GB (2 x 4GB) DDR3-1600 Memory

(£58.69 @ Ebuyer)

Storage:

Seagate Barracuda 1TB 3.5" 7200RPM Internal Hard Drive

(£35.94 @ Aria PC)

Video Card:

XFX Radeon R9 280X 3GB Black Edition Double Dissipation Video Card

(£186.34 @ Scan.co.uk)

Case:

NZXT Source 210 (Black) ATX Mid Tower Case

(£30.25 @ Scan.co.uk)

Power Supply:

EVGA 500W 80+ Bronze Certified ATX Power Supply

(£36.98 @ Novatech)

Total:

£511.31

Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available

Generated by PCPartPicker 2014-12-28 17:53 GMT+0000

0
June 25, 2016

You want to play skyrim? so don't touch those AMD cpus, don't get me wrong, I still love AMD, and if they bring out something that can come close to intel cpus, I will go for AMD...the problem with those AMD cpus is that they are like a lottery, in same games they are on par with top tier Intel cpus, in some others, they can't come even close to i3 cpus... I think industry is still in favor of Intel. Rarely can you find any game or app which use all 8 cores, but if you do AMD can be slightly better, not even noticeable, as far as aftermarket cooler is concerned, you can overclock your cpu a little with the stock cooler on an Intel cpu, but if you want a good one, still budget, I suggest you buy thermalright true spirit 120m

0
June 25, 2016

Seriously!? it cant take a 750 watt powersupply cause A: thats

crazy

amounts of power and B why doesnt that show up on Pc part picker?

also the GTX 970/980 and R9 290/290x are

waaaaay

out of budget!

0
June 25, 2016

this i would go for, except i would really love to step up that 500 watts to a 750 watts just to be safe..

:D

0
June 25, 2016

What kind of frames would I be getting on this rig? would it allow me to be playing HIgh settings? or play at 1080p?

0
June 25, 2016

Again what kind of rates would I be getting with this build?

0
June 25, 2016

When being on a tight budget, I'd either recommend the I5 4460 + h81/b85 board or amd fx 8320 + cheap board. With gaming as priority, intel is the clear winner and the I5 does support every gpu out there to get it to it's fullest. The fx 8320 clearly wins in video rendering, though, so that should be your choice if that is your priority.

If you plan on upgrading in a few months, I'd recommend to get a z97 board and a pentium g3280, though. It will do better than the amd one in most games but won't be optimal in rendering. But with the z97 board, it leaves the option to go for a broadwell I7 later. However, might as well save money and get a b85 board + xeon e3-1231v3. Basically an I7 without integrated gpu. Would be the strongest choice in all mentioned tasks.

To sum it up: I5 4460 + b85 board for now without upgrading later and gaming as priority. Amd fx 8320 with productivity as priority. Xeon e3-1231v3 +b86/h97 board as optimal choice, no upgrades needed. Or z97 + pentium to upgrade once you can.

0
June 25, 2016

As for the build, very high - ultra settings on 1080p with 60 fps. Depending on the game.

0
June 25, 2016

again though, I still think 750 watts is a tad excessive even if I do overclock! (which isnt possible on the i5-4460

0
June 25, 2016

depends on the game, the i5-4460 is pretty much the same with the 4690k except it has lower frequency and is not unlocked. i have the same procie and a r9 270x i play most game on ultra 1080p at 50-60 fps (farcry 4/battlefield 4/nba 2k15). i have skyrim too and the fps goes well over 70+, with your 280x im guessing 10-20 more frames than my 270x.

0
June 25, 2016

I choose the GTX 760, although the R9 280X is faster, but it do a great work in CUDA acceleration apps (Blender, 3DSmax .... ) dividig render time by 2, 3 or morz times

I choose also the FX for great value and good performances at midway between an i5 and i7, for gaming, according to the last Toms FX review, the FX won't bottleneck a mainstream card

PCPartPicker part list

/

Price breakdown by merchant

CPU:

AMD FX-8350 4.0GHz 8-Core Processor

(£125.00 @ Aria PC)

CPU Cooler:

Cooler Master Hyper 212 EVO 82.9 CFM Sleeve Bearing CPU Cooler

(£25.34 @ Scan.co.uk)

Motherboard:

Gigabyte GA-970A-UD3P ATX AM3+ Motherboard

(£63.54 @ Aria PC)

Memory:

Corsair Vengeance 8GB (2 x 4GB) DDR3-1600 Memory

(£62.68 @ CCL Computers)

Storage:

Seagate Barracuda 1TB 3.5" 7200RPM Internal Hard Drive

(£35.94 @ Aria PC)

Video Card:

Asus GeForce GTX 760 2GB DirectCU II Video Card

(£154.73 @ Ebuyer)

Case:

NZXT Source 210 (Black) ATX Mid Tower Case

(£30.25 @ Scan.co.uk)

Power Supply:

XFX 550W 80+ Bronze Certified ATX Power Supply

(£46.99 @ Amazon UK)

Total:

£544.47

Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available

Generated by PCPartPicker 2014-12-28 18:08 GMT+0000

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-fx-8370e-cpu,39...

0
June 25, 2016

Lol at 750w. 400w would be about the highest a single gpu rig would draw.

0
June 25, 2016

r9 280x is only above 5-15 FPS depending on games with the gtx 760 in real time gaming.

gtx 760 will do the job at 1080p ultra settings has cuda cores helps in video rendering, will consume less power, requires less power to operate and is cheaper.

r9 280x will do the job better at 1080 ultra settings but not by a large margin, will consume more and require more power is a little expensive but it has 3gb memory and 256bit bus width.

0
June 25, 2016

i'll see you try running a r9 290x on 400 watts that is a single gpu

well many says the r9 280x would run on a 500-600 watts QUALITY PSU.

manufacturer side says power requirements needs 750 watts.

is up to you to decide to go what the manufacturer says just to be safe, or just try what others have done already.

0
June 25, 2016

The 290x has an average power draw of 250w under full load with 1ms spikes to ~330w. The i5 4460 consumes around 60w power maximum (stress test). So we're at 380w. 20w for hdd's and optical drives and you're at 400w. Maximum power consumption. I'm myself running a gtx 680 and an i7 4790k, both overclocked. I get along with my 450w psu very well, have personally not seen over 350w total system power usage.

0
June 25, 2016

Ram, Fan(s), CPU cooler, led strips, extra hdd, sdd and whatever peripheral he would want to add in the near future (sli/xfire). i just said just to be safe i did not say it would not work. and by the way nice info on the r9 290x now i know i won't need to upgrade my 600 watts psu just to gpu upgrade my 270x into a 280x/290x

:D

0
June 25, 2016

Not entirely true, if you compair the FPS over say 50 titles you will find that FX chips fit between I3's and I5's

0
June 25, 2016

Rough figures...

Cpu + OC =150w

Mobo + accessories =100w

Gpu =200w

You do

not

need a 750w psu, a decent 500-550 will be just fine and still have plenty of headroom. Ideally you want to max out a pc at no more than 80% of a psu capability, and thats running programs such as occt with linpack etc which drive a cpu @110% + ram @90% or kombuster which will drive a gpu @105-125%. Normal usage with any of your listed programs will see a 500w psu @70% which is ideal. Not to mention a bunch cheaper cost while maintaining quality.

0
June 25, 2016

Intel series are the winners as Intel CPUs tend to have stronger cores and also tend to use less power.

0
June 25, 2016

What about this

I reveised my build and now I am here, however I am not sure about my case/mobo yet so some help would be apreciated:

http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/p/g34mRB

  • Build one

http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/p/NVwKxr

  • Build two

What do ya think I prefer build one as its cheaper and has better parts however I am unsure of the case (NZXT Source 210 Black) and my Mother Board

Board two was what I was working on when I made this thread however I relise its pretty shambolic and expensive.

0
June 25, 2016

that xeon looks perfect for your video rendering / editing and it will most likely do the job for gaming.

0
June 25, 2016

The second one doesn't make sense at all. Getting a k cpu with a h board = senseless. Either get a z97 board (taking you to more expense than the xeon) or step down to an i5 4460/4590 with the b85 board. And then it comes down to what is more important to you, gaming or video editing. The xeon would do much better in video editing, the 280x build better in gaming.

0
June 25, 2016

I have spent a lot of time doing a bit more research and am beginning to feel comfortable with my build so, without further ado, here it is:

http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/p/R4R6P6

What do you think of the graphics card?

Also do you think the motherboard will be able to cut the mustard as they say or do think there are better ones in the same price point (£40 - ~£60) (mATX/ATX)

0
June 25, 2016

If you don't plan to crossfire, the motherboard is fine. If you want to crossfire later, should choose

http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/part/gigabyte-motherboard-ga...

for just $7 extra, though.

0
June 25, 2016

R9 280x = 600w psu, can use a tier1 or 2a 550w psu.

R9 280 = 550w psu, can use tier 1 or 2a 500w psu.

Gtx 760 = 500w psu, performs almost to the 280x level in most games, ties in some and exceeds in a few, but main thought should be Cuda, for blender work, etc which will exceed handily both AMD gpus.

0
June 25, 2016

I think that you should wait the GTX 960, which you can use it for CUDA acceleration with Blender and some Adobe softs, and obviously for gaming

:D

(The GTW 960 will be slightly better than the GTX 770)

I think that is the best solution for you

Related Questions

This is the very first question

Hello guys! This is the first post in this site Read More

Views

2k

Votes

4

Answers

2

January 08, 2016

report values not showing up.

I have a crystal report which I pass a DataSet to using VB.NET. The report was working fine, but then I make some changes to the import query and now nothing shows up in the crystal report. Crystal do Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

12

September 06, 2005

Event log doesn't overwrite as needed in SP4

Hello All, After upgrading from SP3 to SP4 on several Windows 2000 PRO machines everything looked fine, but from time to time applications can't write to the event log. When I try to view the appl Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

9

May 11, 2003

"Failed to self-register XYZ.dll"

Hi there, I wrote a OLE-automation-server DLL in VB4.0. I use Installshield Express to install it as part of my program on the target computers. Now on some computers I get the message "Failed to Read More

Views

5k

Votes

0

Answers

2

November 08, 1998

Please help understand these notes on image processing

Can someone please help me understand these lecture notes... On the right of the page; What does "normalised by one notion of the area of a pixel" mean? On the first formula for A, Is that a Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

3

February 05, 2009

Can someone please explain this paragram on the chain rule in image processing

Please see the screenshot, How is 3133030 got from 10103322? Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

1

January 05, 2009

AD on 2003

We have created an AD Domain on Windows 2000 Server with no problems. We just created an AD Domain on Windows 2003 and we're getting some weird problems. Both of these domains are behind firewalls Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

15

May 11, 2003

ADDT ASP Upload Error " Type mismatch: 'tNG_isFileInsideBaseFolder' "

I am trying to create a simple insert record and upload image function on an ASP page built using Adobe Dreamweaver Developer Toolkit. I have done this many times before with no problem, however, i ha Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

0

November 02, 2008

MYSQL Select query with custom ORDER BY

Hi, is it possible to customize the order of the returned rows in mysql? Example: I have a Table with a column "name", now I want to have all entries ordered by name, but I want the entries Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

5

July 02, 2010

Folder Redirection in Server 2003

We have a Windows Server 2003 Standard Ed. Is there a way to redirect the users my documents to a folder that has already been created on the server? Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

2

July 05, 2007

Partiton magic  version 8.0 having error 1523 while executing batch

I followed the partition magic 8.0 wizard to partition my hard disk while rebooting  I came across this problem  "error 1523 while executing batch" What can I do to solve this prob Read More

Views

1k

Votes

0

Answers

2

May 11, 2003

Please explain this paragraph in image processing (screenshot attached)

Two questions; How is the equation (10.1-15) formed? "are isotropic for rotation increments of 90 degrees and 45 degrees respectively" What does this mean Read More

Views

987

Votes

0

Answers

7

January 05, 2009

xp_cmdshell with net use

Hi, when I use 'net use \192.168.0.1\c$ password /user:username' at the command prompt, it works fine.  But if i try to use it in sql with " exec master..xp_cmdshell 'net use \19 Read More

Views

919

Votes

0

Answers

5

April 11, 2003

hp ux11

i have a hp ux11 server. and i edited the /etc/resolv.conf to use my win2003 server dns server. That went fine, however, I would like to go the other way and add an entry on my win2003 dns to resolve Read More

Views

564

Votes

0

Answers

3

October 12, 2009

Using an application over a LAN

I have written an application that needs to be used on a LAN.  The application setup wizard takes care of registering everything on a single PC, but how do you go about writing a setup program th Read More

Views

490

Votes

0

Answers

9

August 07, 1998

Need subnet of 12 IPs.

Please, Can someone help me to create a subnet consisting of 12 IP's. Thanks.. Read More

Views

489

Votes

0

Answers

5

April 11, 2003

Drill down in a cross-tabl report

Hello, Would some experts to show me if it is possible to do drill-up or drill-down (or both) in a cross-tab report? I would also like to know if it is possible to control what fields to be displayed/ Read More

Views

406

Votes

0

Answers

0

September 06, 2005

Using RDO, Enterprise V Professional

We would like to use RDO on our project made up of 4 developers. Do we need to have a copy of Enterprise for each developer or is it possible to use Professional for those developers not writing the R Read More

Views

474

Votes

0

Answers

6

January 07, 1998

Can't Edit IIS Metabase.xml

We do this on every windows 2003 server and never had an issue. We cannot edit the IIS Metabase.xml We have stopped IIS and made change click save, no problem but it does not take the new information. Read More

Views

465

Votes

0

Answers

0

July 05, 2007

copy directorires - HP UNIX

Let's say my source file is /A/B/C/D/file1, and mytarget directory is /E/F/G, I want the result should look like this. /E/F/G/A/B/C/D/file1 I am using rsync to copy the files older than x no of da Read More

Views

489

Votes

0

Answers

14

September 12, 2009